Prospect Hill, 1830s Greek Revival house in Athens, Tennessee - $1.4 Million

Prospect Hill for sale in Athens, Tennessee. Built in the 1830s, Greek Revival style, a piece of history, elegant interior detailing, hand-carved mantels, original wood doors, chef’s kitchen with custom cabinetry, cottage, 7.8 acres of land, 5 bedrooms, 5148 square feet. $1,495,000.

Prospect Hill 1830s Greek Revival house Athens Tennessee - 1 - front view

House overview

History and Significance

Prospect Hill is a distinguished historic estate in Athens, Tennessee, with deep ties to the town’s development and Civil War history. Constructed in the 1830s, the stately mansion was built by Samuel Cleage and Thomas Crutchfield for Judge Thomas Nixon Van Dyke, a prominent lawyer and president of the Hiwassee Railroad.

During the Civil War, the home served both Confederate and Union forces. In 1864, Van Dyke, a Confederate sympathizer, was arrested by Union forces and imprisoned in Ohio. During his imprisonment, General William T. Sherman used Prospect Hill as his headquarters. The home also briefly hosted Confederate General Nathan Bedford Forrest.

Architectural features

Prospect Hill is an impressive two-story Greek Revival mansion showcasing classic columns, symmetrical proportions, and elegant interior detailing.
Upon entering, visitors are greeted by a sweeping staircase and elegant 12-over-12 sash windows that flood the rooms with natural light.
The home’s beautifully restored plaster walls, hand-carved mantels, and meticulously replicated original wood doors reflect its rich history.
Stunning balcony porches with sidelights and transoms offer serene views of historic magnolias.
The heart of the mansion is its chef’s dream kitchen, blending historical charm with modern luxury. Custom cabinetry, beautiful appliances, and an open layout make it perfect for both cooking and entertaining.

The property also includes a second residence, a 1955 cottage offering 1,248 square feet with three bedrooms, one bath, and a large garage ideal for guest space or multi-generational living.

Prospect Hill, encompassing both residences and approximately 7.8 acres of land, is currently on the market for $1,495,000, presenting a unique opportunity to own a piece of Athens’ rich history.

This estate stands as a testament to the rich history of Athens, Tennessee, reflecting both the grandeur of antebellum architecture and the resilience committed to preserving its past.

House details

Bedrooms: 5
Bathrooms: 3
Interior area: 5,148 sqft
Lot size: 7.8 Acres
Year built: 1830s
Style: Greek Revival
State: Tennessee
Price: $1,495,000
Photos and info: Tanya Bates
Contact: Tanya Bates, Silver Key Realty
- Tel: (423) 368-7342
- Office: (423) 405-5157
- Email: tbates.realestate@gmail.com
Address: 129/131 Elizabeth Street, Athens, TN 37303